Showing posts with label welsh rarebit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label welsh rarebit. Show all posts

Sunday, 8 January 2012

Welsh Rarebit Week - Part 6 of 6 - Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall


Hugh Bingley-Bongley! He’s mainly a Meat man, so how will he manage with a cheese task?
The Good Life wannabe did quite well but fell in the same hole that James Martin did - too many flavours! Less is more you celebs, less is more! KISS (keep it simple, stupid). A nice, simple-to-make offering this time, but how did it measure up?
You can find the complete recipe here : httphttp://www.bbc.co.uk/food/recipes/database/perfectwelshrarebit_13772.shtml
Nice try all the same…..
Taste - 2.5
Overpowered. How sad that in a dish based on cheese, top chefs try to dominate the cheese with their own combinations of strong flavours. Why couldn’t they add a couple of delicate, COMPLIMENTARY flavours? Hugh’s meal tasted very confusing, was I meant to taste the cheese or the additions? They were, definitely, exclusive.
Presentation - 2
It looked orangey/brown. With a hint of something worse. Is this good? It’s cheese on toast. But it looked like something different. Disappointing.
Ease/Effort - 3
This was a really easy method to understand, but a little difficult to follow. “Warmed beer”? What does that mean? I warmed mine in a pan for 10 minutes. Right or wrong? Who knows?
Scores On The Doors:
Sue Marchant - 13
The Foody - 11.5
Delia Smith - 11
Country Life Dot Com - 9
Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall - 7.5
James Martin - 5

Saturday, 7 January 2012

Welsh Rarebit Week - Part 5 of 6 - Delia Smith


Delia’s back, smarting from her spanking in the Scrambled Egg challenge. Would this see her rise from the ashes and re-establish her reputation?
Delia fared very badly last time out, so this was a good chance for her to reclaim her crown as Kitchen Queen. Unfortunately when I made this recipe I didn’t have an onion for the grated onion (doh) which probably affected the end product. This recipe was quick, easy, and tasted pretty good!
You can find the complete recipe here : http://www.deliaonline.com/recipes/welsh-rabbit-rarebit-with-sage-and-onions,1373,RC.html
A great comeback effort Delia, good work…..
Taste - 3.5
Cheesey. Hint of mustard (Colman‘s, natch). Soaked into the toast. This tasted like a “proper” cheese on toast. I wish I’d had an onion to add it in grated form, but the recipe was very nice without it anyway. The rounded teaspoon of mustard powder together with cayenne pepper made it possibly a little too spicy for the average palate, but that’s a minor fault. I’d go for level, not rounded.
Presentation - 3.5
Delia’s scrambled egg was grey, thanks to early pepperisation, and this dish was also slightly off colour. It looked pretty good but not perfect, and the cheese mixture melted very nicely and evenly. The cayenne pepper added a lovely splash of colour.
Ease/Effort - 4
Easy and quick, and does exactly what you want. Cheese on toast in short order, but modify the spicy ingredients if you don’t like hotter foods. The recipe was extremely simple to follow, and gave a great result, can’t be bad.
Scores On The Doors:
Sue Marchant - 13
The Foody - 11.5
Delia Smith - 11
Country Life Dot Com - 9
James Martin - 5
Running Order:
Day Six - Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall.

Friday, 6 January 2012

Welsh Rarebit Week - Part 4 of 6 - Sue Marchant


Into the fray plunges Sue Marchant, a lovely young lady who can be found on the air with BBC Radio Norfolk in the evenings….
Sue isn‘t a chef. This recipe is not written down. Anywhere. It just so happens that after Scrambled Egg Week I was wondering what the next taste test would be, and Miss Marchant suggested cheese on toast (a very sensible suggestion from a vegetarian). She also sent me her own method for producing “cheese on toast” and it worked rather well!
There is no online version of this recipe, but you can tune in to Sue’s radio show between 7 and 10, weekdays, here :http://www.bbc.co.uk/norfolk/
So to the all important verdict…..
Taste - 4.5
This recipe required mozzarella instead of the ubiquitous cheddar. I have rarely used this cheese so it was something of an adventure, as was the use of tomato and basil in this Welsh Rarebit experiment. The end result was bleeding lovely, a really fresh flavour, with added “stringiness” which is all part of the cheese on toast experience as far as I’m concerned. Bootiful.
Presentation - 4.5
For such an easy recipe the end result looks rather splendid, and would fool you into thinking that lots and lots of work had gone into making it. The mozzarella is much lighter in colour than the cheddar, and this not only makes the crispy pieces stand out more, it also makes the added tomato and basil look fantastic.
Ease/Effort - 4
A very simple version of this classic food, with an amazing end product. Sue’s recipe was only three lines in length yet gave us a real taste explosion. Fantastic effort. The only small drawback was the instruction to toast the bread on just one side - and then not tell us which side the cheese goes on. It’s a small point, and I split the difference, flipping one slice of toast and adding the cheese to one untoasted slice and one toasted. The taste was very similar, but I slightly preferred the “toasted side down” version. I wonder which is the right one?
Scores On The Doors:
Sue Marchant - 13
The Foody - 11.5
Country Life Dot Com - 9
James Martin - 5
Running Order:
Day Five - Delia Smith.
Day Six - Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall.

Thursday, 5 January 2012

Welsh Rarebit Week - Part 3 of 6 - The Foody Dot Com


A leading gastronomy website takes its turn at claiming the cheese on toast crown….
A competition of highs and lows so far, would the drama continue with The Foody‘s recipe? The Foody subtitled their recipe header with the name in Welsh - Caws Pobi - which was nice. Also admirable was the quote “whatever you choose to call it - it’s still cheese on toast”. Correctamundo! I found this a simple and delicious version.
Find the recipe online here : http://thefoody.com/cheese/welshrarebit.html
Taste - 4
Simplicity returned after yesterday’s over-indulgence, and what a relief. The taste of the cheese came through VERY strongly in this recipe, which has to be the main purpose of Welsh Rarebit. There were also a couple of larger pieces of onion (see Ease/Effort) which I personally liked but others may not, and one mouthful was particularly “mustard-y”, hinting that I ought to have mixed for a little longer. The addition of onion to the mixture was new to me but worked fabulously. Delicious.
Presentation - 4
As the picture shows, this has a very “proper“ look of cheese on toast about it. Cheese dripping and melting over the edge of the toast, and the surface of the cheese with crispier brown spots here and there. Whether the beer helps the browning I’m not sure, maybe we’ll know by the end of the competition?
Ease/Effort - 3.5
It was nice to find a brilliantly simple recipe again, and it was very, very easy to follow. Mind you, there does seem to be a small error. What does “Place half the mixture on toast on each slice of toast“ mean? That’s a very minor criticism though. If you struggle to chop onions without crying, you will be shedding buckets as you grate the onion here, I’ve never grated an onion before and it seems that the chemicals you release “gently” when slicing are hurled violently into the air when grating! Altogether, easy and effective, despite the onion tears.
Scores On The Doors:
The Foody - 11.5
Country Life Dot Com - 9
James Martin - 5
Running Order:
Day Four - Sue Marchant.
Day Five - Delia Smith.
Day Six - Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall.

Wednesday, 4 January 2012

Welsh Rarebit Week - Part 2 of 6 - James Martin


The Scrambled Egg Champion attempts to defend his crown….
Off to a reliable start yesterday thanks to Country Life’s website recipe, next into battle was “Baby” James Martin. He stormed his way to victory in the last taste test thanks to not only a tasty recipe but great presentation - could he do it again?
No. James’ recipe had the longest list of ingredients for this week, and although I followed it exactly the finished meal was nowhere near as good as his scrambled egg masterpiece. Terribly disappointing.
Find the recipe online here : http://www.bbc.co.uk/food/recipes/database/welshrarebit_72299.shtml
Taste - 1.5
There were so many different flavours involved that they all seemed to merge and become unrecognisable. Is there really any need for mustard AND Worcester sauce AND Tabasco? The texture was rather doughy too, which was not the nicest. Plus the addition of the egg - unbeaten - I’ll put that down as “unconventional”? Afterwards I even felt slightly nauseous....
Presentation - 1.5
Ideally I think you should see a few small brown patches on the top of your cheese on toast - not with Mister Martin’s recipe though. After placing the cheese mixture on top of the toast, it was returned to a low/medium grill, and VERY quickly developed one large brown crispy area on each slice. The finished product looked a little like two miniature yellow and brown Millennium Domes - on toast. Not 100% appetising. A bonus half a point for trying to dress it up with tomato chutney.
Ease/Effort - 2
This was quite a labour intensive recipe. Heating milk, but not boiling, adding cheese to it until it dissolved, removing to cool then adding other ingredients at various other moments. I did manage to follow the recipe to the letter but even the slightest distraction would probably prove disastrous. I was really disappointed that the cheese mixture expanded into dome shapes and very nearly burned under the grill.
Scores On The Doors:
Country Life Dot Com - 9
James Martin - 5
Running Order:
Day Three - The Foody Dot Com.
Day Four - Sue Marchant.
Day Five - Delia Smith.
Day Six - Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall.

Tuesday, 3 January 2012

Welsh Rarebit Week - Part 1 of 6 - Country Life Dot Com


Off to a flying start, and introducing two ingredients I had never considered before….
Our first recipe was the “Perfect” entry, and turned out to be “Perfect Welsh Rabbit” from Country Life’s website. There are a couple of interesting historical notes attached: “Yes, rabbit, not rarebit, as Welsh rabbit turned up in print in 1725 and rarebit 60 years later. In 1747, Hannah Glasse had recipes for rabbits for Scotland, Wales and England. The first was just toasted cheese on toast and butter, Welsh rabbit had mustard added, and English rabbit had red wine soaked into the toast.”
The inclusion of mustard was something I had only heard about in the last week or so, when both Old Bob AND Woolpack Wally told me that they like to include it, during pre-competition discussions at the Grumpy Old Men‘s Club. Equally, the inclusion of beer was a new one on me, so I had some concern as to what kind of beer to use. A few of this week’s recipes demand beer, be it “brown ale”, “beer” or “strong beer” so I plumped for Marston’s Pedigree which seems to tick all those boxes.
As always the photo is my own version of the recipe.
Find the recipe online here : http://www.countrylife.co.uk/countryside/article/116565/Perfect_welsh_rabbit.html
Taste - 3.5
A good start and a tasty, easy recipe. I’ve never included mustard or beer in cheese on toast before, but they certainly provided a bit of depth and “oomph”, making the whole thing a pleasure to eat.
Presentation - 2
Looks just like cheese on toast traditionally does. There’s toast at the bottom, and cheese on the top. Not bad, not great, just…..cheese. On. Toast. Will any of the other recipes try to do anything different?
Ease/Effort - 3.5
With minimal ingredients the recipe was simplicity itself, but would that produce a bland, uninspiring finished product? The first job was to “grate the cheese”. Again, I have always just sliced the cheese, so this was another new one on me. This was then mixed with butter, Worcester sauce, mustard and beer to produce a “rough paste”, which was then spread over toast and grilled. The recipe tells you to grill for “a minute or so” until the mixture singes in patches, but this actually took four minutes until the required effect appeared.
Scores On The Doors:
Country Life Dot Com - 9
Running Order:
Day Two - James Martin.
Day Three - The Foody Dot Com.
Day Four - Sue Marchant.
Day Five - Delia Smith.
Day Six - Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall.

Monday, 2 January 2012

Cheese On Toast / Welsh Rarebit Week


Off we go again, road-testing six different ways of producing comfort food favourite "cheese on toast". For simplicity's sake it will be known as Welsh Rarebit from now on....
Six different versions of a favourite recipe. The Scrambled Egg Week was great fun, so we're off again, slapping cheese onto toast, together with various other ingredients, and using different ways of cooking the whole lot to produce a childhood memory meal.
The draw was carried out earlier, and the order of the week will be:
Day One - Perfect Welsh Rarebit (where "perfect Welsh Rarebit" is entered into Google, and the first recipe is used). This time the recipe is provided by Country Life Dot Co Dot UK. This is first up, later today.
Day Two - James Martin. The winner of the Scrambled Egg challenge, will photogenic Mister Martin retain his crown?
Day Three - The Foody Dot Com. A gastronome's website present their own special take on our recipe.
Day Four - Sue Marchant. Sue is a BBC Radio Norfolk DJ, presenting the evening show in great style. Indeed, it was Sue who suggested we try "cheese on toast" recipes, and she emailed her own unique version to Norfolk Single Dad last week.
Day Five - Delia Smith. Let's be having ya Delia! After narrowly avoiding relegation with her scrambled egg, Mrs Reliable is back to try and regain lost kudos.
Day Six - Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall. Somewhat of a wildcard, who knows how modern-day Good Life devotee Hugh will perform? Will River Cottage be top of the pops?
The ingredients are collected (see pic), the recipes are printed. Good luck everyone!